On Tuesday, March 7, 2006 the Greeley City Council passed two new noise ordinances. The first, in response to a complaint by Merv Davies, requires city businesses to get a special license if they have live music and are within 100 feet of a residence. Mr. Davies and his family live in a loft above a local restaurant/bar in the downtown area named Corleone’s and he appearantly thinks the establishment is too noisy.
Anyone familiar with the city of Greeley knows that the downtown area is not exactly what would be termed residential. There may be lofts above the businesses, but it is primarily a commercial district, in fact a commercial district that the city has been attempting to revive for the last 20+ years. If the Davies family has such a problem with the noise level from Corleone’s why didn’t they just move to a quieter location? This ordinance will do little to encourage downtown businesses to stay open and improve the area.
The other problem with this ordinance is it’s citywide implications. Greeley is not exactly a town booming with entertainment options. The city council has decided that the peace and quiet of one man that has chosen to live in a commercial area is more important than the rights of businessmen, the ability for musicians and artists to perform and the entertainment of thousands of local patrons in a city of nearly 80,000 people. This is a matter between a business owner and a resident that should have been settled privately between them. This is not an issue that is even worthy of the attention of our City Council.
In a related item, the city council also passed an ordinance raising the fine for a first time noise ordinance to $1000. Greeley is a college town and as such there are often college parties in the student’s off-campus residences. These loud college parties were the motivation for this ordinance. Maybe it’s just me, but $1000 for a first time offense of a noise ordinance seems a little out of control. I have been to college parties before, as many of us I’m sure have, and sometimes they get a bit out of control. Attempting to raise the fine to a level that is out of reach for most university students will only further encourage these students to leave this town and seek entertainment elsewhere. Greeley residents need to take a hard look at the policies their city council is engaging in and take an active role in setting these policies. Greeley will never outgrow the stigma of being a stinky cow town if we continue to discourage our students from spending their time here and convince local businesses that they should move to a more friendly city.